| Miscellaneous | Manhattan (1887-1891) |
| Manhattan Second XI (1887-1890) | |
| Brooklyn (1888) | |
| McCully's XI (1889) | |
| Bedford (1889-1891) | |
| United Lacemakers (1889) | |
| New York East Second XI (1890) | |
| Kings County Second XI (1890) | |
| Kings County St George (1893-1894) | |
| Manhattan Vice-Captain's XI (1899) | |
| Brooklyn Second XI (1899) |