| North Yorkshire and South Durham Premier League | Normanby Hall (2013-2015) |
| Darlington (2016-2017) | |
| Richmondshire (2018-2023) | |
| Miscellaneous | Darlington (2008) |
| Darlington Railway Athletic (2011-2012) | |
| Normanby Hall (2014) | |
| Richmondshire (2018-2023) | |
| Seaham Harbour (2024) |