| Miscellaneous | Upper Canada College (1853-1871) |
| Canada (1856-1868) | |
| Upper Canada College Old Boys (1857) | |
| Canada East (1857) | |
| Toronto (1861-1876) | |
| Canada West (1861-1863) | |
| All-Comers (1863) | |
| Civilians (1863-1868) | |
| Upper Canada College Past and Present (1873) |