| Liverpool Premier League | New Brighton (1940-1963) |
| Wallasey (1942-1944) | |
| Miscellaneous | New Brighton Colts (1937) |
| Wallasey Grammar School (1940) | |
| New Brighton Schoolboys (1940) | |
| New Brighton (1940-1953) | |
| Wallasey Strollers (1941) | |
| JM Synge's XI (1941) | |
| Wallasey A (1942) | |
| Wallasey (1942-1943) | |
| Royal Air Force (1944) | |
| New Brighton Second XI (1955-1972) |