| Test | West Indies (1928-1930/31) |
| Main FC | Jamaica (1910/11-1934/35) |
| Other FC | West Indians (1928-1930/31) |
| West Indies (1928-1930/31) | |
| West Indies XI (1928/29) | |
| Miscellaneous | Jamaica (1910/11) |
| Port Antonio (1910/11) | |
| Middlesex County (1926/27) | |
| West Indians (1928-1930/31) |