| Test | South Africa (1888/89-1891/92) |
| Main FC | Western Province (1889/90-1890/91) |
| Other FC | South Africa (1888/89-1891/92) |
| Cape Town Clubs (1889/90) | |
| Miscellaneous | Marlborough College (1871-1872) |
| Savernake Forest (1871) | |
| Mother Country (1878/79-1881/82) | |
| Western Province Cricket Club (1886/87) | |
| Western Province (1888/89-1895/96) | |
| Cape Colony (1888/89-1891/92) | |
| South Africa (1888/89) | |
| Cape Town (1889/90) |