| 4 | JH Anderson | Griqualand West v Western Province | 1896/97 | f4622 |
| 4 | FE Woolley | Transvaal v Marylebone Cricket Club | 1909/10 | f7898 |
| 4 | VY Richardson | Transvaal v Australians | 1935/36 | f15252 |
| 4 | B Mitchell | Eastern Province v Transvaal | 1939/40 | f16770 |
| 3 | E Beech | Transvaal v Kimberley | 1890/91 | f3582 |
| 3 | RO Schwarz | Western Province v Transvaal | 1906/07 | f7058 |
| 3 | SD Snooke | Transvaal v Western Province | 1906/07 | f7058 |
| 3 | AEE Vogler | England v South Africa | 1909/10 | f7881 |
| 3 | FE Woolley | South Africa v England | 1909/10 | f7903 |
| 3 | JH Sinclair | The Rest v Transvaal | 1911/12 | f8436 |
| 3 | AW Redick | Transvaal v PW Sherwell's XI | 1913/14 | f9004 |
| 3 | EC Murray | PW Sherwell's XI v Transvaal | 1913/14 | f9004 |
| 3 | AW Nourse | Australian Imperial Forces v South Africa | 1919/20 | f9525 |
| 3 | SD Snooke | Griqualand West v Transvaal | 1920/21 | f9787 |
| 3 | AW Nourse | Transvaal v Natal | 1921/22 | f10118 |
| 3 | WH Brann | Transvaal v Eastern Province | 1921/22 | f10133 |
| 3 | AW Nourse | England v South Africa | 1922/23 | f10446 |
| 3 | CAG Russell | South Africa v England | 1922/23 | f10446 |
| 3 | CM Francois | Western Province v Griqualand West | 1923/24 | f10759 |
| 3 | MJ Susskind | Natal v Transvaal | 1923/24 | f10768 |
| 3 | HG Deane | Western Province v Transvaal | 1929/30 | f13008 |
| 3 | EH Hendren | Transvaal v Marylebone Cricket Club | 1930/31 | f13349 |
| 3 | B Mitchell | England v South Africa | 1930/31 | f13356 |
| 3 | B Mitchell | England v South Africa | 1930/31 | f13385 |
| 3 | WR Hammond | South Africa v England | 1930/31 | f13385 |
| 3 | JP McNally | Rhodesia v Griqualand West | 1931/32 | f13734 |
| 3 | SF Viljoen | Griqualand West v Transvaal | 1934/35 | f14828 |
| 3 | B Mitchell | Natal v Transvaal | 1939/40 | f16749 |
