| 5 | KR Meherhomji | Muslims v Parsees | 1934/35 | f14821 |
| 4 | CW Wright | Parsees v Lord Hawke's XI | 1892/93 | f3821 |
| 4 | EL Tomkins | Parsees v Europeans | 1900/01 | f5460 |
| 4 | DD Kanga | Europeans v Parsees | 1901/02 | f5714 |
| 4 | DD Kanga | Europeans v Parsees | 1903/04 | f6209 |
| 4 | FL Sprott | Hindus v Europeans | 1910/11 | f8129 |
| 4 | PB Irfani | Parsees v Muslims | 1916/17 | f9298 |
| 4 | JG Navle | Muslims v Hindus | 1919/20 | f9529 |
| 4 | BE Kapadia | Hindus v Parsees | 1920/21 | f9785 |
| 4 | BE Kapadia | Europeans v Parsees | 1921/22 | f10110 |
| 4 | Dilawar Hussain | Europeans v Muslims | 1925/26 | f11428 |
| 4 | BE Kapadia | Marylebone Cricket Club v Europeans and Parsees | 1926/27 | f11805 |
| 4 | G Brown | Indians v Marylebone Cricket Club | 1926/27 | f11811 |
| 4 | KR Meherhomji | Marylebone Cricket Club v Bombay | 1933/34 | f14452 |
| 4 | DD Hindlekar | Western India v Bombay | 1934/35 | f14873 |
| 4 | HA Nakhuda | Europeans v Muslims | 1935/36 | f15194 |
| 4 | ES Maka | Bombay v Gujarat | 1951/52 | f19474 |