| 6 | AJ Stewart | Berkshire v Surrey | 1995 | a9306 |
| 6 | JC Buttler | South Africa v England | 2013 | a22695 |
| 5 | JT Murray | Surrey v Middlesex | 1975 | a1443 |
| 5 | KM Krikken | Surrey v Derbyshire | 1998 | a11323 |
| 5 | JN Batty | Gloucestershire v Surrey | 2001 | a13645 |
| 5 | AJ Stewart | Lancashire v Surrey | 2002 | a14291 |
| 5 | JN Batty | Kent v Surrey | 2007 | a18194 |
| 5 | Kamran Akmal | West Indies v Pakistan | 2013 | a22670 |