| 5 | JW Barnes | Rishton v Rawtenstall | 1937 | llwc235 |
| 5 | DJ Pearson | Rawtenstall v East Lancashire | 1983 | llwc758 |
| 5 | JT McGregor | Rawtenstall v Lowerhouse | 2005 | llwc1039 |
| 4 | A Waite | Rawtenstall v Ramsbottom | 1950 | llwc306 |
| 4 | A Haigh | Rawtenstall v Nelson | 1965 | llwc507 |
| 4 | PS Graham | Rawtenstall v Accrington | 1981 | llwc711 |
| 4 | BA Manning | Colne v Rawtenstall | 1985 | llwc779 |
| 4 | P Barnes | Church v Rawtenstall | 1990 | llwc843 |
| 4 | JD Simpson | Rawtenstall v Ramsbottom | 1995 | llwc914 |