| 4 | A Waite | Rawtenstall v Ramsbottom | 1950 | llwc306 |
| 3 | GB Fenton | East Lancashire v Rawtenstall | 1922 | llwc34 |
| 3 | N Coupe | Bacup v Rawtenstall | 1937 | llwc229 |
| 3 | P Colbourne | Ramsbottom v Rawtenstall | 1955 | llwc371 |
| 3 | J Hayton | Rawtenstall v Haslingden | 1955 | llwc376 |
| 3 | G Holt | Colne v Rawtenstall | 1957 | llwc401 |
| 3 | TG Holt | Burnley v Rawtenstall | 1975 | llwc637 |
| 3 | PJ Plummer | Rawtenstall v Burnley | 1975 | llwc637 |
| 3 | CR Miller | Burnley v Rawtenstall | 1992 | llwc870 |
| 3 | SR Lemon | Rawtenstall v Nelson | 2003 | llwc1012 |
| 3 | JNH Morgan | Rawtenstall v Todmorden | 2008 | llwc1079 |
| 3 | LJ Wright | Rawtenstall v Enfield | 2016 | llwc1187 |
| 3 | DN Phillips | Rawtenstall v Rishton | 2023 | llwc1365 |
| 3 | DR Salpietro | Rawtenstall v Lowerhouse | 2024 | llwc1386 |