| 4 | BL Cohen | Hawthorn-East Melbourne v St Kilda | Glenferrie Oval, Melbourne | vca1923 |
| 3 | SJ Hastings | Melbourne v Carlton | Albert Ground, Melbourne | vca1913 |
| 3 | CB Willis | Richmond v Prahran | Toorak Park, Melbourne | vca1915 |
| 3 | AD Kelso | St Kilda v Hawthorn-East Melbourne | Glenferrie Oval, Melbourne | vca1923 |
| 3 | BA Onyons | Hawthorn-East Melbourne v Melbourne | Albert Ground, Melbourne | vca1925 |
| 3 | EC Ramsden | Northcote v Collingwood | Westgarth Street Oval, Melbourne | vca1927 |
| 3 | CB Willis | South Melbourne v Prahran | Toorak Park, Melbourne | vca1928 |
| 3 | BA Onyons | Prahran v Melbourne | Melbourne Cricket Ground, Melbourne | vca1951 |
| 3 | ET Austen | St Kilda v University | St Kilda Cricket Ground, Melbourne | vca1954 |
| 3 | RH Watson | University v St Kilda | St Kilda Cricket Ground, Melbourne | vca1954 |
| 3 | HA Dickens | St Kilda v Northcote | St Kilda Cricket Ground, Melbourne | vca1971 |
| 3 | WE Bowes | Prahran v Carlton | Princes Park, Melbourne | vca1973 |
| 3 | WH Bailey | Fitzroy v University | Fitzroy Cricket Ground, Melbourne | vca1975 |