| 4 | C Craig | Essendon v University | Windy Hill, Melbourne | vca1787 |
| 3 | HA Halfpenny | Richmond v Northcote | Richmond Cricket Ground, Melbourne | vca1772 |
| 3 | WB Miller | St Kilda v University | St Kilda Cricket Ground, Melbourne | vca1774 |
| 3 | H Bartholomew | Carlton v Richmond | Princes Park, Melbourne | vca1775 |
| 3 | HA Halfpenny | Essendon v Northcote | Westgarth Street Oval, Melbourne | vca1782 |
| 3 | HSB Love | Fitzroy v Carlton | Fitzroy Cricket Ground, Melbourne | vca1788 |
| 3 | HA Halfpenny | St Kilda v Northcote | St Kilda Cricket Ground, Melbourne | vca1797 |
| 3 | H Bartholomew | Essendon v Richmond | Windy Hill, Melbourne | vca1800 |
| 3 | JL Ellis | St Kilda v Prahran | Toorak Park, Melbourne | vca1803 |
| 3 | HA Halfpenny | Carlton v Northcote | Westgarth Street Oval, Melbourne | vca1813 |
| 3 | JRH Woodford | University v Fitzroy | University Oval, Melbourne | vca1816 |
| 3 | HF Guthrie | Carlton v St Kilda | Princes Park, Melbourne | vca1823 |
| 3 | SE Wootton | University v Hawthorn-East Melbourne | University Oval, Melbourne | vca1828 |
| 3 | WM Flintoft | North Melbourne v Melbourne | North Melbourne Cricket Ground, Melbourne | vca1835 |
| 3 | J Flanagan | Melbourne v North Melbourne | North Melbourne Cricket Ground, Melbourne | vca1835 |
| 3 | J Flanagan | Melbourne v North Melbourne | North Melbourne Cricket Ground, Melbourne | vca1835 |
| 3 | JL Ellis | North Melbourne v Prahran | Toorak Park, Melbourne | vca1837 |